AAMI won the Fair Trader of the Year Award (Victorian Government, 1996).

AAMI won both Victorian and National Australian Customer Service Awards in the category of large business (Australian Customer Service Association, 1997)

AAMI was awarded the inaugural Sir Edmund Rice Ethics Award (1997)

AAMI was named among the 'Best Employers to Work for in Australia', ranked fifth among companies with more than 1000 employees, in the award given by the Australian Graduate School of Management (2001)

AAMI won the Teleperformance CRM Grand Prix Award (2003)

AAMI was three times awarded 'Best Insurance Web site' (Australian Banking and Finance Awards, 2003, 2004, 2005)

AAMI won the top award 'General Insurance Company of the Year' in the 2004 Australia and New Zealand Insurance Industry Awards

AAMI was a finalist in the 'Services to the Community' Award for the AAMI Skilled Drivers program (2004 Australia and New Zealand Insurance Industry Awards)

AAMI won 'Best General Insurance Product' for AAMI comprehensive car insurance policy (Australian Banking and Finance Awards 2004)

AAMI won a 2004 Queensland Road Safety Award for the AAMI Crash Index (a research and community education initiative)

AAMI was State and National Winner, Australian Safer Communities Award 2004 for AAMI Firescreen Index

AAMI was State Winner and National Highly Commended, Australian Safer Communities Award 2004 for partnership between AAMI and Victoria State Emergency service

AAMI won a Fire Awareness Community Service Award (Victoria) 2004

AAMI won State and National Charter Awards, 2004 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI won the Victorian Customer Charter Award, 2004-2005 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI won the Victorian Customer Service CEO of the Year Award, 2005-06 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI won the Victorian Australian Service Excellence (Large Business) Award, 2005-06 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI won the National Customer Service CEO of the Year Award, 2005-06 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI won the National Australian Service Excellence (Large Business) Award, 2005-06 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI won the Best of the Best Award (under 10,000 staff), 2005-06 Australian Service Excellence Awards (Customer Service Institute of Australia)

AAMI is consistently ranked among Australia's top 20 companies by corporate reputation (Harris Interactive Australia)